Scratch Made | Small Batch | Darn Tasty!
This week's Bake!
Check out this week's beauties!!
This week's BUTTER SWEET BAKE includes 6 different cookies!!
Our Featured 6 Cookies:
Santa, Santa
Cindy Lou
Santa PBMnM
Red Velvet Crink
Gingerbread
Minty Mountain Hop
Feel Free to Mix and Match!
PLUS, we added a ton more in the store of different varieties!!
Cookies are available in limited quantities. When they are gone, they are gone! Pricing is per cookie.
Baked fresh EVERY WEDNESDAY and shipped/delivered on Thursdays.
**NEW** FREE Local Delivery Available to select Zip Codes. $15 minimum order.
Out of stock
$3.99
Cindy Lou
Our Double Chocolate Chip Cookie topped with chocolate ganache, crushed candy canes, and a candy ...
Out of stock
$3.99
Cookie Monster
Our blue, browned butter chocolate chip cookie with white chips, semi dark chips, Chips Ahoy, and...
Out of stock
$3.99
Raspberry Thumb
Our DELICIOUS Shortbread Cookie topped with raspberry jam. 100% a must try!
Out of stock
$3.99
Applebomb
*New and Improved Recipe* Our Cinnamon Oatmeal Cookie with dried apple and caramel bits.
Out of stock
$3.99
Wakka, Wakka
A Browned Butter, brown sugar cookie, with Biscoff Cookies, white chips, and stuffed with Cookie ...
Out of stock
$3.99
Santa PBMNM
Cookies for Santa? I say Yes!!
Everything you love about our PBMNM Cookie but with a holiday flair.
Everything you love about our PBMNM Cookie but with a holiday flair.
Out of stock
$3.99
Santa, Santa
Our signature Sugar Cookie dressed up for the holidays. A perfect addition to a big glass of milk.
Out of stock
$3.99
Brown Shuggah
Why does it taste so good? Let me tell you! It's a Brown Sugar Cookie with Real Maple Syrup and H...
Out of stock
$3.99
Froggy
It's a take on our Circus, Circus sugar cookie, which includes white chips and chocolate SPRANKLE...
Out of stock
$3.99
Fluffer Nutter
Feel like a kid again with that nostalgia of Peanut Butter and Marshmallow, now all in a cookie! ...
Out of stock
$3.99
Minty Mountain Hop
Take a trip to the Andes with this Chocolate, Chocolate Chip Cookie with Andes Mint Chocolates. T...
Out of stock
$3.99
Cookies 'N Cream
This one is a show stopper! The name says it all! Oreo's and chopped Cookies & Cream candy bar.
Out of stock
$3.99
The Brooke
Brooke's Favorite Oatmeal Walnut Chocolate Chip Cookie. Forget the raisins on this one.
Out of stock
$3.99
Original Chocolate Chip
This is where it all started at Butter Sweet Baked. The Original Chocolate Chip takes the traditi...
Out of stock
$3.99
Circus, Circus
The ultimate sugar cookie with white chocolate chips, and multi-colored SPRANKLES mixed throughou...
