Scratch Made | Small Batch | Darn Tasty!
Products
Out of stock
$3.99
Applebomb
*New and Improved Recipe* Our Cinnamon Oatmeal Cookie with dried apple and caramel bits.
Out of stock
$3.99
Brown Shuggah
Why does it taste so good? Let me tell you! It's a Brown Sugar Cookie with Real Maple Syrup and H...
Out of stock
$3.99
Cindy Lou
Our Double Chocolate Chip Cookie topped with chocolate ganache, crushed candy canes, and a candy ...
Out of stock
$3.99
Circus, Circus
The ultimate sugar cookie with white chocolate chips, and multi-colored SPRANKLES mixed throughou...
Out of stock
$3.99
Cookie Monster
Our blue, browned butter chocolate chip cookie with white chips, semi dark chips, Chips Ahoy, and...
Out of stock
$3.99
Cookies 'N Cream
This one is a show stopper! The name says it all! Oreo's and chopped Cookies & Cream candy bar.
Out of stock
$3.99
Fluffer Nutter
Feel like a kid again with that nostalgia of Peanut Butter and Marshmallow, now all in a cookie! ...
Out of stock
$3.99
Froggy
It's a take on our Circus, Circus sugar cookie, which includes white chips and chocolate SPRANKLE...
Out of stock
$23.94
Gift Pack - 6
Gift Pack Includes:
🍎: Applebomb: oatmeal with caramel bits and dried apples🎃:Punkindoodle: pum...
🍎: Applebomb: oatmeal with caramel bits and dried apples🎃:Punkindoodle: pum...
Out of stock
$3.99
Minty Mountain Hop
Take a trip to the Andes with this Chocolate, Chocolate Chip Cookie with Andes Mint Chocolates. T...
Out of stock
$3.99
Original Chocolate Chip
This is where it all started at Butter Sweet Baked. The Original Chocolate Chip takes the traditi...
Out of stock
$3.99
Raspberry Thumb
Our DELICIOUS Shortbread Cookie topped with raspberry jam. 100% a must try!
Out of stock
$3.99
Santa PBMNM
Cookies for Santa? I say Yes!!
Everything you love about our PBMNM Cookie but with a holiday flair.
Everything you love about our PBMNM Cookie but with a holiday flair.
Out of stock
$3.99
Santa, Santa
Our signature Sugar Cookie dressed up for the holidays. A perfect addition to a big glass of milk.
Out of stock
$3.99
The Brooke
Brooke's Favorite Oatmeal Walnut Chocolate Chip Cookie. Forget the raisins on this one.
Out of stock
$3.99
Wakka, Wakka
A Browned Butter, brown sugar cookie, with Biscoff Cookies, white chips, and stuffed with Cookie ...
